Asylum seeker issue shouldn’t stop frank Australia-PNG discussions

During a whirlwind visit to Papua New Guinea yesterday and today, Australian PM Kevin Rudd spoke with PNG PM Peter O’Neill on a range of topics. Rudd also made several announcements on the trip, including Australian support for law and orderimproved travel arrangements for PNG citizens and support for the Ramu-Madang highway and a courthouse building project in Port Moresby.

Asylum seekers and the conditions at the Manus Island detention centre were a priority issue in the discussions.

Development Policy Centre Director Professor Stephen Howes told Radio National Breakfast on Monday morning that the Manus Island detention centre was controversial in both Australia and PNG, but that there was a price to be paid for prioritising a single issue.

“My sense is that if you look at recent visits or statements, we have become very reluctant to say anything critical of the PNG government. Not that we should be hostile by any means, but as a long-time friend, a close neighbour and also a very important aid donor, with the half a billion dollars we give every year, there has to be some allowance for a critical, frank dialogue,” Professor Howes said.

Professor Howes highlighted the sovereign wealth fund as one example where Australia could play a useful role. Australia had been advising PNG on the fund, but in recent times progress has “pretty much come to a halt”.

“The fear and risk is that concerns about Manus and not wanting to offend anyone will result in this issue being downgraded,” he said.

Professor Howes also spoke on the positive steps the aid program has made to improve its effectiveness in PNG, particularly in moving away from an overreliance of advisors. However, he said there was still debate between PNG politicians and AusAID around the question of impact and whether aid funds should be used for new projects or on maintaining existing infrastructure and services.

In a separate interview with Fairfax Media, Professor Howes also spoke on the crisis in PNG’s university sector and the need for tertiary education reform. In 2008, Rudd helped set up the Garnaut-Namaliu Commission on Tertiary Education, and “given his personal involvement” in the initiative it would be good if he refocused on this issue, Howes said.

Watch Stephen’s video interview with Fairfax Media or listen to his interview on Radio National.

image_pdfDownload PDF

Ashlee Betteridge

Ashlee Betteridge was the Manager of the Development Policy Centre until April 2021. She was previously a Research Officer at the centre from 2013-2017. A former journalist, she holds a Master of Public Policy (Development Policy) from ANU and has development experience in Indonesia and Timor-Leste. She now has her own consultancy, Better Things Consulting, and works across several large projects with managing contractors.

1 Comment

  • It would appear from this interview with Richard Marles that the topic of a sovereign wealth fund was indeed canvassed in the talks between the PMs so let’s hope this is a positive sign of things to come. In terms of ‘challenging conversations’, I would like to see more oxygen given to the poor performance of Australian banks, the AFP and Austrac in exercising appropriate vigilance regarding funds being spirited out of PNG into Cairns, Sydney, the Gold Coast, etc.

Leave a Comment