Comments

From Daniel Holonga on Elections and Politics in Papua New Guinea
Please register me for any of your seminars.
From Matt Woolf on Why charter cities have failed
I can't respond directly under your last comment for some reason, Alex, so I'll do so here. Lots of big ideas! If you want to go down another rabbit hole, check out Georgism. Here are some good links: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/your-book-review-progress-and-poverty I hope to write about this and other topics for this blog. I also plan to start a Substack at some point, but I'm not sure when. I'll keep you posted!
From Alexander Kurz on Why charter cities have failed
Wow, thanks for the link, this looks super interesting. Anything else on "big ideas for big problems" you would like to share? Do you have a personal blog (substack?) or some other place where I can follow your work?
From Charli pabakera on Honiara, the village-city
An excellent analysis of evolution of Solomon Isl. I agree with all variables identified that contributed to the birth of new Solomon Islands.
From Asiata on Christianising Samoa’s constitution and religious freedom in the Pacific
Perhaps something like this: https://uoa-my.sharepoint.com/:w:/g/personal/wasi131_uoa_auckland_ac_nz/EaUByBDbSShBlxCq8guNqJ8BWtZyNjvmTL7uF56PifW22g?e=kbCr3T
From Paul Palosualrea Pavol on The Papua New Guinea land grab
My good country fellow. The words you wrote are very true and have repeatedly being said in a lot of campaign, awareness and consultation gathering but have fallen on hard rocks or brick wall. But let's not stop talking. Thank you very much.
From Paul Palosualrea Pavol on The Papua New Guinea land grab
Our good Prime Minister of our great country PAPUA NEW GUINEA must act immediately and cancel the fraudulent SABL LEASES and return land to legitimate traditional and customary land owners. We lost almost everything thing in all our forest. Papua New Guinea businesses can not do such in other countries and it is very bad for foreign businesses to come and take our forest in front of our eyes.
From Anton kaso on Landowner identification in PNG: a job for government
Ankave tribe are still struggling to get their ILG.
From Matt Woolf on Why charter cities have failed
It really is a fascinating topic and idea. I love reading about big ideas for big problems, even if they don’t make sense or work out in the end. I also think that there is a lot of truth in what charter city advocates say regarding externalities and immigration. But why not just do special reform zones? It may be less flashy compared to charter cities, but accomplish the same thing and at a lower cost. I wish I included that in this post. It seems that could be a really great way for the charter city idea (albeit in a more mild form) to truly work. By the way, there’s a great article on charter cities which makes comparisons to special reform zones and special economic zones here: https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/EpaSZWQkAy9apupoD/intervention-report-charter-cities A long read, but really great.
From Alexander Kurz on Why charter cities have failed
It is all about numbers? I think it is also about ethics, agency, democracy, justice, power, etc I recently listened to https://ecociv.org/podcast/episode-37-bridget-mugambe/ which gives some background from an African perspective.
From Alexander Kurz on Why charter cities have failed
Thanks for the reply. I had not heard of charter cities before and I find it fascinating to think about why they fail (or not). Starting from the currently dominant economic thinking, the idea of charter cities sounds as if it should work (as argued by mainstream economists such as Romer). So if we understand well why they fail we will also understand better why our current economic system in the large fails us. And maybe also get some hints of how to change our economic system. I am interested in "radical incremental change". Radical in the sense that we need to change direction if we want to act on climate change, preserve biodiversity, and provide for the needs of everybody. Incremental because it is impossible to design a working system from scratch.
From Matt Woolf on PNG’s minimum wage
This was an interesting read! Pretty striking how PNG minimum wages and Australian minimum wages follow diametrically opposed paths. Could be interesting to look at unit labor costs which are supposed to be one of the best measures of international competitiveness.
Subscribe to our newsletter