Comments

From Joelson Anere on PNG’s unanswered constitutional questions pile up
My name is, Joelson Anere, please use correct spelling of a persons name. For your information, by operation of law, James Marape election is a procedural error because of Peter O'Neill withdrawal when nominations had already closed.
From Robert McPhail on A plan for Fiji to open its borders
I would come back to Fiji under these circumstances.
From Michael on PNG’s unanswered constitutional questions pile up
JK that’s a good point. Also the case Namah is faced with relates to Namah storming the court house to arrest the Chief Justice in 2011. It’s difficult for anyone to face the same court expecting a favorable result. He says he will appeal the case, so let’s see how it goes.
From Michael on PNG’s unanswered constitutional questions pile up
Hi Jelson, thanks for the comments. Basically, we will never know the answers to these questions unless court rules on them. At the moment, each man has his own interpretation 😊
From JK Domyal on PNG’s unanswered constitutional questions pile up
One question. As a layman I am of the view that SC only reviews application made by aggrieved parties of a lower court. In the case of Beldan N tribunal; when the tribunal end a decision for dismissal from office for the member for Vanimo Green, he appealed for a SC review on his dismissal; thus he was successfully granted a permanent stay order pending the review. And he continue to serve as MP for Vanimo Green. In the 29 May SC decision, the SC could refer to the stay order and the pending judicial review then making an outright decision to effect his dismissal. This in my view is tantamount to violation of natural justice and an unprecedented case of a decision made outside the rule of court. What about the permanent stay order and the judicial review currently pending for Beldan N. Some legal expert on this can shed some light here.
From Kuntala Lahiri-Dutt on Women as recovery enablers: listening to ni-Vanuatu market vendors
Excellent piece! Interesting research findings that rescue women from the victimhood trap, and presents a positive outlook!
From Kuntala Lahiri-Dutt on India’s COVID diplomacy
Interesting article!
From Joelson Anere on PNG’s unanswered constitutional questions pile up
Firstly, bro, I will comment here and later on the blog site. Secondly, the substantive matter must be dealt with by the full Supreme Court Bench comprising all 9 judges for purposes of clarity and uniformity in the interpretation of the Constitutional questions highlighted and still afoot. Thirdly, it is unconstitutional for Former Prime Minister Peter O'Neill to withdraw his nomination when nominations had already been closed by the Speaker. Importantly, Peter O'neill nomination shouldn't have been entertained by the Speaker because technically, Namah was already suspended pending judicial court clarification as Member for Vanimo-Green. This raises the issue of the integrity of the Member for Vanimo-Green, while under suspension as per section 61, 62, and 63 of the Organic Law on the Integrity of Political Parties and Candidates Law. Fourthly, the Speaker can be removed by Parliament via a VONC with a absolute majority vote in favor and via the Organic Law on Duties and Responsibilities of Elected Leaders, which is administered by the PNG Ombudsman Commission. If this happens, the deputy Speaker will be acting Speaker as per Parliamentary Standing Orders. A Permanent Speaker can only be made when the currentParliament cycle ends and a new Parliament is sworn into Parliament as per the Constitution.
From James on Women as recovery enablers: listening to ni-Vanuatu market vendors
Very insightful read. Great work to all involved!
From Fiona Hukula on Mi gat Y: Is Digicel PNG’s loan scheme predatory?
Thanks Martin, Michelle and Stephen. A really informative piece that illustrates the another form of 'dinau' which many of our people find themselves entangled in.
From Fiji Think Tank on Fiji Cabinet hides while nation laughs
Great piece Bruce. On point.
Subscribe to our newsletter